- A study of voting patterns across the US from 2008 to 2016 revealed that in counties where Donald Trump picked up swing votes, death rates were 15% higher than in counties where Democrats made gains.
- Researchers believe that hopelessness and fear impacted voter preferences in counties where more people are dying "deaths of despair" from causes like suicide, drugs, and alcohol.
- The finding aligns with other research about the psychology of conservative voters, which shows fear can be a motivator.
- The researchers believe better life expectancy rates might have tipped the scales in favor of Hillary Clinton in states including Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin.
The US is one of the richest countries in the world, but death rates for middle-aged, white, working-class Americans are rising. That's especially true when it comes to causes like suicide, drugs, and alcohol.
The phenomenon has given rise to a troubling new term in public health: deaths of despair.
Such deaths are most common among white, non-Hispanic men in their early 50s who don't have a college degree. That group is increasingly dying earlier from causes like alcohol and drug poisoning, suicide, alcoholic liver disease, and cirrhosis (liver failure).
New research suggests the trend might have impacted the 2016 election.
In a study released Wednesday, researchers from Columbia University found a link between higher rates of these so-called deaths of despair and more swing votes cast for President Donald Trump.
The researchers behind the study, which was published in the Journal of General Internal Medicine, analyzed US counties where Trump picked up votes in 2016 as compared to John McCain in 2008. It revealed that in places where death rates went up, so did voters' tendencies to choose the Republican candidate.
"Although life expectancy is increasing in many parts of the country, especially in urban areas, we're not seeing nearly the same gains in rural and middle America," lead author Lee Goldman, chief executive of Columbia University Irving Medical Center, said in a release. "We shouldn't underestimate the degree to which some portions of the country have been left behind in terms of their health."
Higher death rates, more Republican votes
For their research, Goldman's team used publicly available voting data from all 3,112 US counties. They compared voting patterns in 2008 and 2016 with changes in death rates from 2000 to 2015. The results showed that counties where more votes went Republican in 2016 than 2008 had a 15% higher age-adjusted death rate than counties that gained Democratic votes.
What's more, counties where Trump picked up more votes in 2016 than McCain did in 2008 had increases in death rates from suicide, alcohol, and drugs that were 2.5 times higher than in counties where Clinton picked up more votes than Obama did.
These elevated death rates were linked with votes for Trump even when the researchers controlled for other socioeconomic and demographic factors like age, race or ethnicity, income, education, unemployment, and health insurance rates.
"Reduced health prospects are an important marker of dissatisfaction, discouragement, hopelessness, and fear, sentiments that may have resonated with voters who sided with President Trump," Goldman said in the release.
The researchers did not suggest that deaths of despair directly caused people to favor Trump, but their finding lends credence to the idea that feelings of fear and despair were predictive of Republican support.
"Although death rates are not the only marker of health and well-being, they might be a marker of relative despair," the researchers wrote. "If so, it is not surprising that deaths related to alcohol, drugs, and suicides rose by 2.5 times as much in counties with a Republican percentage gain, compared with counties with a Democratic percentage gain."
Fear and hopelessness can sway voters to pick Republican candidates
The new findings align with other data researchers have collected about the psychological differences between liberal and conservative voters.
Feeling scared, for example, has been shown to make voters more conservative. That's what happened in the US after September 11, and the link has been seen in other countries around the world as well. People may also embrace conservative views as a way to "explain, order, and justify inequality among groups and individuals," as one 2003 review of studies put it.
Fear isn't the only factor at play in a voter's choice. Other surveys have found that personal values also play a huge role in how we vote, and are better predictors of support for a candidate than political ideologies.
In 2016, for example, Trump supporters were more likely to agree with statements like "people who are poor just need to work harder" and "vacations are for weaklings," suggesting a pull-yourself-up-by-your-bootstraps mindset is alive and well in his base.
But psychologists have also demonstrated how malleable those partisan views can be.
In one recent study, a team of researchers from Yale University temporarily swayed some conservatives to express more liberal views on social issues by having them imagine they were imbued with superhuman powers of survival.
"We have one mind, and it can operate consciously and unconsciously," John Bargh, the author of that study, told Business Insider.
A team of researchers from Harvard also found that people's stance on Syrian refugees can shift just from imagining themselves in the refugees' shoes.
Based on the new county-specific data, the Columbia researchers said the 2016 election could have tipped in Hillary Clinton's favor if death rates had dropped, even modestly, between 2000 and 2015 in the battleground states of Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin.
Of course, it's impossible to say what would have happened if those states had become healthier and saw fewer deaths of despair. But there's no denying that our feelings of safety, health, and hopelessness can impact our decisions about political candidates.
Most Watched Videos
Most Read News
- Kayes century sets up easy Bangladesh cricket win
- Crowds protest latest deadly rebel raid in DR Congo
- Olympian Emmanuel Nartey successfully completes his doctoral thesis
- MOFRI organises UN Day unity walk
- Oshiomhole Cries Out: Powerful Forces Want Me Out Of APC
- Meet Janet A. Owusu: Ghana’s Young Female Graphic Designer
- Pan Africanism: A Desire For Power Or A Desire For Equality?
- B/A: Bra Dea Foundation Gives Mathematical Sets To 5,000 JHS Students
- The Divisive Nature Of Politics In Ghana
- Karpowership Grabs Best Quality Independent Power Plant Of The Year Award
- There is hope for Ghana: But not in what you think
- Dr. Mahamudu Bawumias Twenty Months In Office, And The True State Of Affairs In The Walewale Constituency
- Assemblyman Elect For Korletsom Electoral Area Support His Community With Two(2) Trips Of Sand, Football And A Set Of Jersey
- The Love Of God Constraintineth Us
- How to Make 300,000 lives wretched
- Emmanuel Game Boy Tagoe Wins WBO Africa Lightweight Belt
- Bukom Fist of Fury Boxbiz Hits Bukom With Bukom Banku Leading The Show
- Raphael Dwamena Meets Legendary Real Madrid Striker Raul Gonzalez
- Jeffery Schlupp Plays Full Throttle As Crystal Palace Suffer Defeat To Everton
- AWCON 2018: Adjoa Bayor And Memunatu Sulemana To Assist In Sunday’s Draw
- Be professional - Valerie Sawyerr to Attorney General
- AMAA 2018: I've done well and hoping to win - Seun Ajayi
- AMAA nomination tells how relevant I am - Gideon Okeke
- Lifestyle: Prince Harry rehearsed an important speech in front of only Meghan Markle, and fans are loving the candid photo
- Live updates from AMAA 2018 in Kigali
- Take a look at the 1st photos from AMAA 2018
- AMAA honour late Chris Ekejimbe at 14th edition in Kigali
- Sports: Titans fail to score on game-winning two-point conversion twice to lose heartbreaker to the Chargers in London
- Lifestyle: Hailey Baldwin is trying to trademark the name 'Hailey Bieber' weeks after she and Justin Bieber were reportedly spotted getting a marriage license
- Tech: 3 reasons you should buy the iPhone XS Max instead of the standard iPhone XS (AAPL)
- Tech: It’s time for tech giants to retire the ‘keynote’ — Apple, Google, and others are all making the same mistake with their product launches
- Barcelona have failed to beat Madrid without Messi since 2004
- Tech: A woman spotted her relatives' call for 'HELP' in photos NOAA took of Hurricane Michael's aftermath, and the program could revolutionize the way people are rescued after disasters
- Lifestyle: I traveled the world for 6 months, and here's the single best piece of advice I can give you for any trip you take
- Raphael Dwamena meets legendary Real Madrid striker Raul Gonzalez
- 2018 AWCON: Ghana In Group A Alongside Algeria, Cameroon And Mali
- Emmanuel Boateng Hails Levante’s ‘Big’ Win Over Real Madrid On Saturday
- Mario Icardi Scores A Stunning Header As Kwadwo Asamoah's Inter Wins Milan Derby [VIDEO]
- 2018 AWCON: Ghana To Play Algeria In Tournament Opener
- Tunisia Sack Head Coach Faouzi Benzarti Just Days After Afcon Qualification
- Boakye-Yiadom Scores A Twice In Red Star Belgrade’s 3-1 Win Over Rad Beograd [VIDEO]
- 2018 Women's AFCON: Ghana to play Algeria in tournament opener